Alexandria Bay: Top 5 Restaurants You NEED to Try!

Go Explore NY
Jul 14
2 min read

Nestled in the heart of the Thousand Islands region, Alexandria Bay isn’t just about scenic views and boat tours — it’s also home to some truly incredible restaurants. Whether you’re cruising the St. Lawrence River or enjoying a weekend getaway, these top 5 must-try eateries will satisfy every craving. From local seafood to wood-fired pizza, here's where to dine like a local in A-Bay:

🍽️ Gal’s Place

Cuisine: Classic American diner
What to order: Jumbo sundaes, peanut butter hot fudge, marshmallow overload, sub sandwiches
Why go: A local favorite with rave reviews—4.8⭐ across 84 reviews Wikipedia+13Restaurantji+13LocalityBiz.com+13 Sirved Mobile Solutions+6Wanderlog+6LocalityBiz.com+6

The North Star Family Restaurant

Cuisine: Family-style comfort food
Specialties: Broccoli-cheese omelets, corned beef hash, loaded nachos, steak & eggs
Why go: Generous portions and friendly service—rated 4.3⭐ from 78 reviews Riverboat Bar / Riverhouse Restaurant Restaurantji

Coffee Pot Cathy’s

Cuisine: Breakfast & café fare
Top picks: Breakfast sandwiches, creative omelets, fresh muffins
Why go: Cozy spot to fuel up before exploring—4⭐ from 56 reviews Wikipedia+7VastTourist+7Wikipedia+7

Riverboat Bar & Riverhouse Restaurant

Cuisine: American pub food with live music
Vibe: Waterfront patio dining with local bands on weekends
Why go: Perfect mix of cocktails, burgers, fresh seafood, and summer entertainment Restaurantji+5Wanderlog+5Yellow Pages+5

Top Of The Bay Tex Mex Bar & Bistro

Cuisine: Tex‑Mex with bay views
Hits: Shrimp tacos, rice bowls, brisket plates, signature margaritas
Why go: Fantastic flavors served rooftop-style overlooking the bay Sirved Mobile Solutions+2Wanderlog+2Restaurantji+2

🗺️ Explorer Tips for Food Lovers

Start your day right at Gal’s Place or Coffee Pot Cathy’s for a hearty breakfast.
Midday: Grab a classic lunch at North Star Family Restaurant.
Afternoon/Dinner: Head to Riverboat Bar for food and music, or relax at Top Of The Bay with margaritas and scenic water views.

🍴 Bonus Eats Worth Checking

Josie’s Pizza at the Bay – highly rated for comfort pizza and casual vibes Sirved Mobile Solutions+2Restaurantji+2Yellow Pages+2 Things to Do Post+1VastTourist+1
Cavallario’s Steak & Seafood – upscale riverfront dining with steak and fresh seafood Yellow Pages+3Wanderlog+3LocalityBiz.com+3

Planning a day out in Alexandria Bay?Kick things off with breakfast, enjoy a lakeside lunch, stroll the marina, and top it all off with sunset cocktails by the river. You’ll experience the full flavor and vibe of this vibrant summer town!